In Nottebohm (Liechtenstein v. Guatemala), the International Court of Justice ruled on 6 April 1955, by eleven votes to three, that Liechtenstein’s claim against Guatemala was inadmissible. Friedrich Nottebohm, a German national who had lived in Guatemala since 1905, became a citizen of Liechtenstein in October 1939; the Court found that nationality was not based on any genuine prior link with Liechtenstein, so Liechtenstein could not bring an international claim for him against Guatemala.

In short: Claimant: Liechtenstein. Respondent: Guatemala. Guatemala’s objection to jurisdiction rejected 18 November 1953. Second judgment, 6 April 1955: claim inadmissible, 11-3. Dissenting: Judges Klaestad, Read and Guggenheim. Rule: nationality must reflect a genuine connection to be invoked against another state.

The parties and the claim

The ICJ’s case page says Liechtenstein “claimed restitution and compensation from the Government of Guatemala” on the ground that Guatemala had acted towards Friedrich Nottebohm, a citizen of Liechtenstein, in a manner contrary to international law. Guatemala objected first to the Court’s jurisdiction and then argued that the claim was inadmissible on several grounds, one of them Nottebohm’s nationality. The Court accepted that plea.

Timeline, as the ICJ records it

DateEventICJ document
1905Nottebohm, born in Hamburg and then a German national, settles in Guatemala and makes it the centre of his businessCase page; judgment summary
October 1939On a visit to Europe, after the start of the Second World War, he obtains Liechtenstein nationalityCase page
13 October 1939Naturalized by a Supreme Resolution of the Prince of LiechtensteinJudgment summary
20 October 1939Takes the oath of allegianceJudgment summary
1 December 1939His Liechtenstein passport is visaed by the Consul General of Guatemala in ZurichJudgment summary
1940Returns to Guatemala and resumes his businessCase page
1943Removed from Guatemala as a result of war measuresCase page
1946Goes to Liechtenstein; the Court says this was because Guatemala refused to admit himJudgment summary
18 November 1953First judgment: Guatemala’s objection to jurisdiction overruledCase page
6 April 1955Second judgment: Liechtenstein’s claim held inadmissibleCase page; judgment summary

What the Court decided

The holding is narrow. The Court’s summary says the question was whether the naturalization granted to Nottebohm could be validly invoked against Guatemala, and that the Court did not propose to go beyond the limited scope of that question. It dealt with it without considering whether the naturalization was valid under Liechtenstein’s own law. Because the claim was held inadmissible, the Court did not rule on Liechtenstein’s demand for restitution and compensation.

The case page states the reasoning in three steps:

  1. The bond of nationality between a state and an individual is what alone gives the state the right to put forward an international claim on his behalf.
  2. “On the international plane, the grant of nationality is entitled to recognition by other States only if it represents a genuine connection between the individual and the State granting its nationality.”
  3. Nottebohm’s nationality “was not based on any genuine prior link with Liechtenstein”, and the sole object of his naturalization was to let him acquire the status of a neutral national in time of war. So Liechtenstein was not entitled to take up his case against Guatemala.

The judgment itself (page 22) defines the test: “nationality is a legal bond having as its basis a social fact of attachment, a genuine connection of existence, interests and sentiments, together with the existence of reciprocal rights and duties.”

On the facts, the summary says Nottebohm had been settled for 34 years in Guatemala, the centre of his interests and business, and that members of his family had said he wished to spend his old age there, while his actual connections with Liechtenstein were extremely tenuous. The Court did not deny Liechtenstein’s right to set its own nationality rules: the judgment says international law “leaves it to each State to lay down the rules governing the grant of its own nationality”, but another state need not recognise a grant that does not reflect a genuine connection.

The vote

The judgment was given by eleven votes to three. Judges Klaestad and Read, and Guggenheim, appended dissenting opinions. The ICJ marks its summary Not an official document and its case overview as provided for information only; the judgment of 6 April 1955 is the authoritative text.

What the case does not cover

The judgment decided whether Liechtenstein could protect one man against Guatemala in 1955; it does not set Guatemala’s nationality rules today. For how Guatemalan and US citizenship combine now, see dual citizenship between Guatemala and the USA, and for the wider period, the Guatemala history timeline.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the Nottebohm case and what did the court decide?

Liechtenstein sued Guatemala at the International Court of Justice for restitution and compensation over its treatment of Friedrich Nottebohm. On 6 April 1955 the Court held Liechtenstein’s claim inadmissible, because his Liechtenstein nationality was not based on a genuine connection with that country.

What was the vote in the Nottebohm judgment?

Eleven votes to three, according to the ICJ’s summary of the judgment. Judges Klaestad, Read and Guggenheim appended dissenting opinions.

Did the ICJ take away Nottebohm's nationality?

No. The Court decided only whether Liechtenstein could put forward a claim on his behalf against Guatemala. The ICJ’s summary says it dealt with that question without considering whether his naturalization was valid under Liechtenstein law.

Who was Friedrich Nottebohm?

A German national born in Hamburg who settled in Guatemala in 1905 and made it the centre of his business. He obtained Liechtenstein nationality in October 1939, returned to Guatemala in 1940 and was removed in 1943 as a result of war measures, according to the ICJ.

What is the genuine connection rule?

The Court said that, on the international plane, a grant of nationality is entitled to recognition by other states only if it represents a genuine connection between the individual and the state granting it.