Goldman’s warbler is a black-and-yellow resident warbler of the high mountains of western Guatemala and neighbouring Chiapas. Knut Eisermann and Claudia Avendaño, in their 2018 paper in the Bulletin of the British Ornithologists’ Club, list it as a species, Setophaga goldmani, “Endemic to the highlands of Chiapas, Mexico, and western Guatemala”, known from just six sites in Guatemala (the paper’s summary says six, though its locality account names the seven places in the table below), all at 2,000-3,750 m. They found it common, with several breeding records, around Todos Santos Cuchumatán in 2014-17.
In short: Range: a total extent of occurrence of about 3,900 km2 (2018), with a single Mexican locality, Volcán Tacaná; Cornell calls the bird almost entirely restricted to Guatemala. Guatemalan sites run from San Marcos to the Cuchumatanes, Totonicapán and Quiché. Name: a species in the 2018 Guatemalan checklist; a population of the yellow-rumped warbler on eBird’s species page, which calls it surely a separate species.
Where it has been recorded in Guatemala
| Place | Department | Record in the 2018 paper |
|---|---|---|
| Environs of Parque Regional Municipal Todos Santos Cuchumatán | Huehuetenango | Reported by Milá et al. (2007); common in 2014-17, with several breeding records |
| Around Hotel Unicornio Azul, Sierra de los Cuchumatanes | Huehuetenango | At least nine seen on 26 February 2011 |
| Finca Chancol, eastern part of the tableland | Huehuetenango | Reported by Nelson (1897) |
| Parque Regional Municipal de San Pedro Sacatepéquez | San Marcos | At least six on 8 February 2012 |
| Ixchiguán | San Marcos | Reported by Milá et al. (2007) |
| Momostenango | Totonicapán | Reported by Griscom (1932); several observations in 2001 and 2002 |
| Chichicastenango | Quiché | Griscom (1932); the easternmost record |
All Guatemalan records come from 2,000-3,750 m. The authors put the total extent of occurrence, a polygon around every known site, at just 3,900 km2, and the potential area of distribution at 9,350 km2 of land above 2,000 m within 50 km of those sites. The dated counts are observations, not a population estimate.
For the town at the centre of the range, see Todos Santos Cuchumatán.
Species or subspecies?
Eisermann and Avendaño say their checklist follows the AOU’s 1998 list and supplements through 2017 with two exceptions, one of them this bird: within the yellow-rumped warbler complex they list resident Goldman’s warbler, S. goldmani, separately from the Myrtle and Audubon’s warblers, which are both winter visitors to Guatemala. Their species account notes that Goldman’s is often considered the same species as the yellow-rumped warbler, as in the AOU list of 1998 and their own 2007 work.
A study published in The Auk in August 2016, reported by the Cornell Chronicle, compared more than 37,000 regions of the birds’ DNA; the evidence suggested that Myrtle and Audubon’s warblers are separate species, and so is Goldman’s warbler. Cornell described Goldman’s warbler as “almost entirely restricted to Guatemala” and said that if given full species status, its restricted range and low numbers would make it an immediate target for conservation.
eBird, read 15 November 2026, still treats Goldman’s on its Yellow-rumped Warbler (Setophaga coronata) page, where it calls the bird a distinctive sedentary population, surely a separate species, found very locally in the highlands of Guatemala. We found no BirdLife International factsheet under the name Goldman’s warbler when we searched its Data Zone on 15 November 2026.
How to recognise it
eBird says Goldman’s males are strikingly black overall, with a mostly yellow throat with white corners. In Guatemala the migrant Myrtle and Audubon’s forms are winter visitors, while Goldman’s is resident.
Related
- Pink-headed warbler, another highland warbler of the region
- Birdwatching in Guatemala
- Todos Santos horse race
Sources
- Eisermann, K. and Avendaño, C. (2018), Bulletin of the British Ornithologists’ Club 138(3), PDF, pp. 150, 203 and 204, read 15 November 2026.
- Cornell Chronicle, ‘Butterbutt’ warbler is likely three different species, DNA reveals, August 2016, read 15 November 2026.
- eBird (Cornell Lab), Yellow-rumped Warbler species page, read 15 November 2026.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Goldman's warbler, and where in Guatemala is it found?
A resident warbler of the highlands of western Guatemala and Chiapas, Mexico. Knut Eisermann and Claudia Avendaño (Bulletin of the British Ornithologists’ Club, 2018) treat it as a species, Setophaga goldmani, known from six Guatemalan sites at 2,000-3,750 m, from San Marcos to Huehuetenango, Totonicapán and Quiché. They found it common around the Parque Regional Municipal Todos Santos Cuchumatán in 2014-17, with several breeding records.
Is Goldman's warbler a separate species?
It depends on whose list you use. The 2018 Guatemalan checklist lists it as Setophaga goldmani, departing from the AOU checklist it otherwise follows, and notes that it is often treated as part of the yellow-rumped warbler. eBird describes it on its Yellow-rumped Warbler page as a distinctive sedentary population, surely a separate species. A 2016 DNA study reported by Cornell found evidence that it is one.
What does a male Goldman's warbler look like?
eBird says males are strikingly black overall, with a mostly yellow throat with white corners. In Guatemala it is resident, while the Myrtle and Audubon’s forms of the yellow-rumped warbler are winter visitors, according to the 2018 checklist.
How small is its range?
Eisermann and Avendaño put its total extent of occurrence at just 3,900 km2, with a potential area of distribution of up to 9,350 km2 above 2,000 m. In Mexico they cite only one locality, Volcán Tacaná.

