From 1946 to 1948, the US Public Health Service (PHS) supported research on sexually transmitted diseases in Guatemala that involved intentionally exposing and infecting people with syphilis, gonorrhea and chancroid without their consent, according to the US Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues. The United States apologised on 1 October 2010, in a joint statement by Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius and in a call from President Barack Obama to Guatemala’s President Álvaro Colom.

In short: The Commission’s report of September 2011 counts 1,308 people intentionally exposed to STDs (prisoners, soldiers and psychiatric patients) and 5,128 who underwent diagnostic testing that continued through 1953. The records of the researcher who led the work, Dr. John C. Cutler, are held by the US National Archives with patient identities redacted. Everything below is what the US government’s own bodies have said, with the date they said it.

The apology, 1 October 2010

The two Secretaries’ joint statement, released by the State Department on 1 October 2010, names the work as the U.S. Public Health Service Sexually Transmitted Disease Inoculation Study of 1946-1948. It opens: “The sexually transmitted disease inoculation study conducted from 1946-1948 in Guatemala was clearly unethical.” The Secretaries wrote that they deeply regretted it and added: “we apologize to all the individuals who were affected by such abhorrent research practices.”

In the same statement they said the conduct during the study does not represent the values of the United States, that today’s regulations for US-funded human medical research prohibit such violations, and they announced two steps:

  • a thorough investigation into the specifics of the case;
  • through the Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues, a body of international experts to report on how to ensure that human medical research around the world meets rigorous ethical standards.

The statement was issued in English and Spanish. It also refers to the many Guatemalan Americans who, in the Secretaries’ words, enrich the United States.

The White House read-out of the same day says President Obama spoke with President Álvaro Colom to express his deep regret regarding the study conducted by the US Public Health Service in the 1940s on sexually transmitted disease inoculation, and to extend an apology to all those affected.

What the Presidential Commission found (September 2011)

After the revelation, President Obama asked the Commission to oversee a fact-finding investigation. Its staff reviewed more than 125,000 original pages of documents and approximately 550 secondary sources, completed a fact-finding trip to Guatemala (in May 2011, the report says) and met Guatemala’s own internal investigation committee, the Commission says. Its report, Ethically Impossible: STD Research in Guatemala from 1946 to 1948, is dated September 2011. The report adds that documents were requested from the government of Guatemala, though none were received.

The report’s figures:

What the report countsFigure
Period of the work led by Dr. CutlerAbout July 1946 to December 1948, with follow-up work through 1953
Intentional exposure experimentsFebruary 1947 to October 1948
Experiments reported by Dr. Cutler32 gonorrhea, 17 syphilis and 1 chancroid
People intentionally exposed to an STD1,308, from three populations: prisoners, soldiers and psychiatric patients
Of those, documented as receiving some form of treatment678
Ages of those in the exposure experiments10 to 72; average subject in their 20s
People who underwent diagnostic testing5,128, including soldiers, prisoners, psychiatric patients, children, leprosy patients and air force personnel at the US base in Guatemala
Deaths noted in Dr. Cutler’s contemporaneous records during the experiments83; the report says the exact relationship between the procedures and the deaths is unclear

The report also states that commercial sex workers were used to transmit disease, and that the majority of them had also been intentionally infected.

Who was involved, per the report. The Pan American Sanitary Bureau (the predecessor of the Pan American Health Organization) sponsored the research through a National Institute of Health grant funded by the PHS Venereal Disease Division and its Venereal Disease Research Laboratory. The Bureau built and supplied a research laboratory in Guatemala City and negotiated agreements giving the researchers authority to work with Guatemalan public health treatment centres, government hospitals, the military, institutions caring for orphans and the insane, and the penal system. Costs were shared by the Bureau, the PHS Venereal Disease Division and the government of Guatemala, which funded staff and supplied facilities. The report names among the research staff directors of Guatemala’s national Public Health Service venereal disease section, the national psychiatric hospital, the national orphanage and the army medical department.

The Commission’s finding. Commission Chair Amy Gutmann, Ph.D., said: “In the Commission’s view, the Guatemala experiments involved unconscionable basic violations of ethics, even as judged against the researchers’ own recognition of the requirements of the medical ethics of the day”. She added: “The individuals who approved, conducted, facilitated and funded these experiments are morally culpable to various degrees for these wrongs.”

The report itself warns that much of the evidence was written years later by Dr. Cutler, that some of his retrospective accounts contain inaccurate data or incomplete descriptions, and that it should be read with those limits in mind.

What the National Archives records contain

The US National Archives has released the Records of Dr. John C. Cutler (CDC, Record Group 442) online, redacting only information identifying each patient (updated 2 August 2011). The originals are open for public research at the National Archives at Atlanta. The Archives cautions that some files contain graphic medical images.

Group of folders (folder titles as the Archives lists them)What they cover
Final Syphilis Report, parts 1-7 and bibliographyThe researchers’ final report
Chancroid Study; Experimental Studies in Gonorrhea; Gonorrheal Experiment No. 1 to #4 and two further dated ones; Gonorrheal Experiments - MilitaryThe gonorrhea and chancroid work, including with the military
Immune and immune-serum experiments No. 1-15, at the Asilo de Alienados and the Penitenciaria CentralDated from 13 May 1947 to 4 July 1948
John C. Cutler’s 1947 Correspondence; 1948 Correspondence; Correspondence on ProjectThe researchers’ letters
Experiment Summary Tables; Summary of All ExperimentsOverviews
Report of Serologic Follow-up on Patients Done at CDC in 1953, Samples Sent From GuatemalaThe 1953 follow-up
Patient lists (penitentiary, insane asylum), index cards, laboratory journals, photographsRecords of individuals, with identities redacted

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

What were the US syphilis experiments in Guatemala (1946-1948), and did the United States apologise?

They were research on sexually transmitted diseases supported by the US Public Health Service in Guatemala from 1946 to 1948, which involved intentionally exposing people to syphilis, gonorrhea and chancroid without their consent, according to the Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues. Yes, the US apologised: on 1 October 2010 Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton and Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius issued a joint apology, and President Obama called President Álvaro Colom the same day to apologise to all those affected.

How many people were exposed in the Guatemala experiments?

The Presidential Commission’s September 2011 report says 1,308 people were intentionally exposed to STDs, from three populations: prisoners, soldiers and psychiatric patients, with commercial sex workers used to transmit disease. The researchers documented some form of treatment for 678 of them. The report also records diagnostic testing of 5,128 people, which continued through 1953.

Who ran the experiments?

The Commission’s report says the activities in Guatemala of the Pan American Sanitary Bureau and the PHS Venereal Disease Research Laboratory were led by Dr. John C. Cutler. The Bureau sponsored the research through a National Institute of Health grant, and the work was carried out with officials and institutions of the government of Guatemala, which also funded staff and supplied facilities.

What did the Presidential Commission conclude?

Commission Chair Amy Gutmann said the experiments involved unconscionable basic violations of ethics, even judged against the researchers’ own understanding of the medical ethics of their day, and that those who approved, conducted, facilitated and funded them are morally culpable to various degrees. The Commission’s report is titled Ethically Impossible.

Where are the records of the Guatemala experiments?

The US National Archives holds Dr. John C. Cutler’s records (CDC, Record Group 442) and has released them online with only the information identifying each patient redacted. The originals are open for research at the National Archives at Atlanta.