The 1958-1959 conflict between Mexico and Guatemala was a fishing dispute that turned into a diplomatic break. A US State Department memorandum dated 4 April 1960 records that the Guatemalan Air Force machine-gunned a number of Mexican shrimp-fishing boats on 31 December 1958. Mexico’s Foreign Ministry (Secretaría de Relaciones Exteriores, SRE) says three fishermen were killed and twenty wounded, that President Adolfo López Mateos broke diplomatic and commercial relations with Guatemala on 23 January 1959, and that relations were restored in September of that year.

In short: Attack on 31 December 1958 (US memorandum, 1960). Casualties: three fishermen dead, twenty wounded (SRE, 2011). Mexico breaks diplomatic and commercial relations: 23 January 1959 (SRE). Relations restored: September 1959 (SRE; the US memorandum says the two countries settled their differences that month). Neither source gives the exact day of the restoration.

Timeline

DateWhat happenedWho records it
24-25 February 1958President-elect Miguel Ydígoras Fuentes, visiting Washington, asks for naval craft to stop poaching by Mexican shrimp boats; his prospective foreign minister raises Mexican encroachment on Guatemalan fishing bedsUS Office of the Historian (FRUS), memorandum of 25 February 1958
March 1958Ydígoras assumes the presidencyFRUS editors’ note
5 December 1958The United States agrees to sell Guatemala a number of surplus demilitarized B-26 bombersUS memorandum of 4 April 1960
31 December 1958Guatemalan Air Force machine-guns Mexican shrimp-fishing boatsUS memorandum of 4 April 1960
23 January 1959López Mateos announces the break in diplomatic and commercial relationsSRE history, 2011
September 1959Diplomatic relations restoredSRE history, 2011; US memorandum of 4 April 1960
27 April 1960State Department authorizes the sale of eight B-26s to Guatemala; Ydígoras accepts the same dayFRUS footnote to the 4 April 1960 memorandum

Two accounts of the attack

The two governments’ records describe the same event from opposite sides. Foreign Relations of the United States (FRUS) is the State Department’s documentary series of US diplomacy. The Mexican account comes from Historia de las relaciones internacionales de México, 1821-2010, volume 2 (Central America), published by the SRE in 2011 and written by Manuel Ángel Castillo, Mónica Toussaint and Mario Vázquez Olivera. It is Mexico’s retrospective, official view.

QuestionUS record (FRUS memorandum, 4 April 1960)Mexico’s Foreign Ministry (SRE history, 2011)
What the boats were doingMexican shrimp-fishing boats “that had ignored orders to leave Guatemalan waters”A presunta transgresión (alleged transgression) of Guatemala’s territorial sea by fishermen from Chiapas
Who firedThe Guatemalan Air ForceAviones de guerra (warplanes) firing on Mexican civilians
CasualtiesNot givenThree fishermen dead and twenty wounded
How the response is describedCalled an incident, with no further characterizationA respuesta desmedida (a disproportionate response)
Number of boats or aircraftBoats not counted (a number of them); aircraft not countedNot given

The SRE account places the incident in a wider complaint: it says that after 1954 Guatemala’s military government treated Mexico as a sanctuary for communists, and that its posture led to provocations on the Soconusco border. That is Mexico’s characterization, published in 2011.

Before the attack: the fishing complaint

The fishing quarrel predates the shooting by ten months. On 25 February 1958, at a White House breakfast for President-elect Ydígoras, Dr. García Bauer, described in the FRUS memorandum as the prospective Foreign Minister, “stated that Guatemala was interested in trying to cut down on Mexican encroachment on Guatemalan fishing beds.” A State Department staff note of the same day records that in a two-hour meeting on 24 February, Ydígoras stressed “his desire for naval craft to prevent poaching by Mexican shrimp boats” and his fear that Mexico might revive its territorial claim against British Honduras (today’s Belize; Guatemala’s own claim is on is Belize part of Guatemala?).

The FRUS editors’ summary of US-Guatemalan relations for 1958-1960 says Ydígoras compensated for his political vulnerability by “engaging in a series of high-profile quarrels with his neighbors”: with Great Britain over British Honduras, and with Mexico over a supposed invasion and, later in 1958, over shrimp fishing. The editors add that the United States disapproved of this adventurism but continued its economic and military assistance.

The break and the restoration

According to the SRE history, the attack drew strong protests from the Mexican government, while nationalist fervor spread in Mexico’s streets, encouraged in large part by the press. When Guatemala gave no satisfactory reply, López Mateos announced the rupture on 23 January 1959. The same account says the so-called Guerra del Camarón (Shrimp War) went no further: in September 1959 diplomatic relations were restored, measures were adopted to prevent similar incidents, and the two countries then began taking concrete steps on other pending border matters.

The US memorandum agrees on the month, saying Mexico and Guatemala “patched up their differences in September, 1959”.

The US bombers caught in the middle

The 4 April 1960 memorandum is about US arms policy, and it explains why Washington appears in this story. On 5 December 1958 the United States had agreed to sell Guatemala a number of surplus demilitarized B-26 bombers. After the attack, the Mexican government asked Washington to withhold delivery. The United States agreed, and told the Guatemalans the suspension was due to the rise in Caribbean tensions.

The hold outlasted the dispute. Even after September 1959, the memorandum says, Washington kept ignoring Guatemala’s requests in order to secure British cooperation in restricting arms shipments to the Caribbean, which irritated relations with Guatemala and weakened the influence of US forces with the Guatemalan military. A footnote records that the State Department authorized the sale of eight B-26 aircraft on 27 April 1960, and that Ydígoras agreed to the offer the same day.

What the records do not say

Neither the US documents nor the SRE history gives the exact day in September 1959 when relations resumed, the number of aircraft involved in the attack, the number of boats hit, or any compensation paid. The SRE history refers readers to chapter 30 of a work by Luis G. Zorrilla for a detailed account.

For the wider sequence of events, see the Guatemala history timeline; for the US role four years earlier, the 1954 coup against Arbenz; and for the older border question with Mexico, was Guatemala ever part of Mexico?.

Sources

Frequently Asked Questions

What was the 1958-1959 conflict between Mexico and Guatemala?

A fishing dispute that became a diplomatic break. A US State Department memorandum of 4 April 1960 says the Guatemalan Air Force machine-gunned Mexican shrimp-fishing boats on 31 December 1958. Mexico’s Foreign Ministry (SRE) says President Adolfo López Mateos broke diplomatic and commercial relations on 23 January 1959 and that relations were restored in September 1959.

How many people died in the 1958 attack on the Mexican fishing boats?

Mexico’s Foreign Ministry, in its 2011 history of Mexico’s relations with Central America, gives three fishermen killed and twenty wounded. The US memorandum of 4 April 1960 gives no casualty figure.

Why did Guatemala attack the Mexican boats?

The US memorandum says the boats had ignored orders to leave Guatemalan waters. Mexico’s Foreign Ministry calls it an alleged (presunta) transgression of Guatemala’s territorial sea by fishermen from Chiapas and describes the air attack as a disproportionate response.

Was it a war?

Neither source describes fighting between the two countries’ armed forces. Mexico’s Foreign Ministry says the so-called Guerra del Camarón (Shrimp War) did not go further than the break in relations, and that measures to prevent similar incidents were adopted once relations resumed.

How did the United States get involved?

The 4 April 1960 memorandum says Mexico asked the United States to withhold surplus demilitarized B-26 bombers it had agreed on 5 December 1958 to sell to Guatemala, and that Washington agreed. The State Department authorized the sale of eight B-26s on 27 April 1960.