Last verified: May 16, 2026
When we rank banks or products on livinginguatemala.com we use weighted 0-100 scores. This page publishes the exact formulas — what is measured, with what weight, and a worked example for each. One is in use (Score 5); Scores 1, 2, 3 and 4 are retired and kept below for the record. On 16 October 2026 we withdrew Scores 2 and 3, and also stopped publishing the Mobile Banking UX Score and the Foreigner-Friendly Bank Score that ran on our bank comparators, because their inputs did not trace to a published source. If you disagree with a weight, you can see the raw data and apply your own.
See also: Methodology · Data sources · How we update.
Scoring philosophy
Three rules:
- Each score has 4-5 weighted components that sum to 100%. More than 5 makes the formula opaque; fewer than 4 ignores important variables.
- The most important component receives 30-40% of maximum weight. When we see a component dominating at >50% it is because that genuinely is the case (e.g., on remittances the effective exchange rate is king).
- Each component is normalized to 0-100 before weight is applied, so units (percentages, dollars, counts) do not artificially tilt the score.
Final score = (component1 × weight1) + (component2 × weight2) + ... + (componentN × weightN)
Where each component is on a 0-100 scale and weights sum to 1.0.
Score 1: Best Bank for USD Cash Exchange (0-100) — retired September 2026
Retired in September 2026. This score is no longer published. Its ATM, app and foreigner-friendliness components were hand-entered figures (ATM counts rounded from bank marketing, app-store ratings from an unrecorded date and a subjective grade from branch visits) that we did not re-check against a source. The bank comparison for changing dollars now uses only published buy and sell rates and Banguat’s reference rate. The formula is kept below as a record.
What it measures: How good a specific bank is at exchanging US dollars for quetzales at the teller. Useful for diaspora receiving USD, tourists arriving with cash, and residents paid in USD.
Formula:
| Component | Weight | What is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Spread tightness | 40% | Lower buy/sell spread = higher score. Spread is calculated as (sell - buy) / sell × 100. |
| ATM access | 30% | Own network + foreign card acceptance. Combination of ATM count and geographic coverage. |
| Foreigner-friendliness | 20% | English-speaking staff, English documentation, ease of opening an account as a non-resident. |
| Mobile app rating | 10% | Average of App Store + Play Store rating. |
Update frequency: Daily for spreads (follows the exchange rate scraper). Monthly for the other 3 components.
Worked example — Bank X (hypothetical):
- Today’s buy/sell spread: buy 7.62, sell 7.78 → spread = (7.78-7.62)/7.78 = 2.06%. Normalized to observed system range (best=0.8%, worst=4.5%): component score = 78/100.
- ATMs: 250 own ATMs + accepts Visa/MC/Plus/Cirrus = 88/100.
- Foreigner-friendliness: bilingual staff at 3 key branches, partial English documentation, opens accounts to non-residents with passport + proof of address = 75/100.
- Mobile app: 4.2/5 average = 84/100.
Score = (78 × 0.40) + (88 × 0.30) + (75 × 0.20) + (84 × 0.10) Score = 31.2 + 26.4 + 15.0 + 8.4 = 81/100
Limitations:
- Does not measure post-opening service quality (complaints, response times, fraud resolution).
- The “foreigner-friendliness” component is subjective — based on manual audit with branch visits.
- Does not include hidden fees (e.g., account maintenance) — those are captured by other scores.
Score 2: Tourist ATM Friendliness Score (0-100) — retired October 2026
Retired on 16 October 2026. This score is no longer published. Its main input, the fee each bank’s ATMs charge a foreign card, is not published by any Guatemalan bank whose tariff we could read (BAC, Promerica, G&T and Banrural publish tariffs and none lists it), and the card-acceptance, fraud and English-menu inputs had no source either. The ATM footprint component had already been dropped on 25 September 2026 because its ATM counts could not be traced to a bank source. The ATM fee comparator now shows only the ATM fees and limits banks publish. The formula is kept below as a record.
What it measures: How good a bank’s ATMs are specifically for a tourist with an international Visa/MC/Plus/Cirrus card arriving for a week. Does NOT measure account-opening quality.
Formula:
| Component | Weight | What is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Fee structure | 35% | International card withdrawal fee. Lower fee = higher score. |
| ATM footprint | 25% | Total count + geographic distribution (not concentrated only in GC). |
| Foreign card acceptance | 20% | Accepts Visa/MC/Plus/Cirrus/AmEx — more networks = higher score. |
| Fraud complaint history | 10% | Public complaints on social media and forums — fewer complaints = higher score. |
| English UX at machine | 10% | The ATM offers an English menu before asking for PIN. |
Update frequency: Quarterly (changes infrequently).
Worked example — Bank Y (hypothetical):
- Fees: Q35 + 3% per international withdrawal. Compared to system range (best=Q15, worst=Q60): score = 60/100.
- Footprint: 180 ATMs across 18 of 22 departments = 85/100.
- Acceptance: Visa + MC + Plus + Cirrus (4 of 5 main networks) = 80/100.
- Fraud: 12 public complaints in the last 12 months — mid range = 65/100.
- English UX: yes, trilingual Spanish/English/K’iche’ menu = 100/100.
Score = (60 × 0.35) + (85 × 0.25) + (80 × 0.20) + (65 × 0.10) + (100 × 0.10) Score = 21.0 + 21.25 + 16.0 + 6.5 + 10.0 = 74.75/100
Limitations:
- Does not measure the exchange rate applied to the international withdrawal (set by the Visa/MC network, not the local bank).
- “Fraud complaints” is based on public mentions, not official SIB records (which are not publicly available with per-ATM breakdown).
- The English UX component is binary at some brands (they have it or do not), which overstates fine differences.
Score 3: Wire Transfer Friction Score (0-100) — retired October 2026
Withdrawn on 16 October 2026 because its inputs were unsourced. The incoming and outgoing fees that made up 60% of the score did not trace to published tariffs: the three banks we could check against their own tariff schedules (BAC, Promerica and G&T) were all wrong, and five banks publish no wire fee we could read. The ranking could not be reproduced, so it was removed rather than re-weighted. The wire transfer fee comparator now shows only the fees banks publish. The formula is kept below as a record.
What it measures: How easy/cheap it is to do incoming and outgoing wires (SWIFT) with a bank. Critical for diaspora sending large amounts, expats paying foreign suppliers, and companies with international operations.
Formula:
| Component | Weight | What is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Incoming wire fee | 30% | What the bank charges to receive a wire. Lower = better. |
| Outgoing wire fee | 30% | What the bank charges to send a wire. Lower = better. |
| Processing speed | 20% | Time from initiation to credit. Faster = better. |
| Documentation complexity | 10% | How many documents requested to authorize the wire. Fewer = better. |
| Online vs in-person | 10% | Can it be initiated online or requires a branch visit? Online = better. |
Update frequency: Quarterly.
Worked example — Bank Z (hypothetical):
- Incoming fee: $25 USD. System range ($15 best, $50 worst) → 71/100.
- Outgoing fee: $40 USD. System range ($25 best, $75 worst) → 70/100.
- Speed: 1-2 business days incoming, 2-3 outgoing. System range (same-day best, 5+ worst) → 75/100.
- Documentation: passport + NIT + wire purpose (3 basic documents) → 80/100.
- Online: yes for corporate banking clients, no for natural persons → 50/100.
Score = (71 × 0.30) + (70 × 0.30) + (75 × 0.20) + (80 × 0.10) + (50 × 0.10) Score = 21.3 + 21.0 + 15.0 + 8.0 + 5.0 = 70.3/100
Limitations:
- Does not measure the exchange rate spread applied to the wire (can be much larger than the fee — this is captured in notes, not in the score).
- “Speed” is estimated — the bank may have good nominal speed but compliance delays if the amount crosses reporting thresholds.
- Corporate vs natural-person fees can differ 2x — we publish both versions separately when applicable.
Score 4: Mortgage Best-Fit Score (0-100) — retired October 2026
Retired on 5 October 2026. This score is no longer published. The per-bank mortgage rates it was computed from had been typed into our data pipeline without a source, and the term, closing-cost and prepayment components were editorial judgements. The mortgage page now shows only Banguat’s published averages and the rates banks print on their own sites. The formula is kept below for reference.
What it measures: How competitive a bank’s mortgage offer is. Useful for residents (local or foreigners with residency) looking to buy a home in Guatemala.
Formula:
| Component | Weight | What is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Effective APR | 35% | Effective rate including fees. Lower = better. |
| Maximum LTV | 25% | Maximum loan-to-value offered. Higher = better for buyer. |
| Term flexibility | 20% | Maximum years of term available. More years = better. |
| Closing costs | 10% | One-time charges (appraisal, closing, escrow covered by bank). Lower = better. |
| Prepayment penalty leniency | 10% | Leniency on prepaying without penalty. More leniency = better. |
Update frequency: Monthly (bank tarifarios) + quarterly for non-rate components.
Worked example — Bank W (hypothetical):
- Effective APR: 8.5%. System range (best 7.2%, worst 12.8%) → 77/100.
- Max LTV: 80%. Range (best 90%, worst 60%) → 67/100.
- Term: up to 25 years. Range (best 30, worst 15) → 67/100.
- Closing costs: ~2.5% of loan. Range (best 1.5%, worst 5%) → 71/100.
- Prepayment: allowed without penalty after year 3 → 60/100.
Score = (77 × 0.35) + (67 × 0.25) + (67 × 0.20) + (71 × 0.10) + (60 × 0.10) Score = 26.95 + 16.75 + 13.4 + 7.1 + 6.0 = 70.2/100
Limitations:
- Per-bank mortgage rates in our data are the publicly advertised ones in tarifarios. The actual negotiated rate with a client may be up to 1.5 percentage points lower (better profile) or higher (aggressive LTV).
- Does not include specialized products like BANVI / FHA-style — only standard commercial mortgages.
- “Closing costs” vary by property value — we use a standardized scenario (Q800,000 property, 80% LTV, 20 years).
- Does not measure post-closing service quality (modification, refinancing processes, etc.).
Score 5: Best Effective Transfer Score — Remittance Comparator (0-100)
What it measures: How good a remittance provider is specifically from the recipient’s point of view in Guatemala — how many quetzales actually arrive, how fast, how convenient pickup is.
This is the most important of the scores because it directly affects diaspora, and because the dominant component (effective exchange rate) can vary 5-10% across providers on the same amount.
Formula:
| Component | Weight | What is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Effective rate after fees | 40% | The most important number: how many GTQ the recipient actually receives per USD sent, after ALL fees. |
| Speed | 25% | Time from send to availability for the recipient. Minutes = better than days. |
| Payout convenience | 20% | Cash pickup network + bank deposit options. More options = better. |
| Sender flexibility | 10% | Payment methods accepted (bank transfer, debit card, credit card, cash at agent). |
| Reliability / uptime | 5% | Frequency of complaints about errors, delays, lost transfers. |
Update frequency: Daily for the effective rate component (follows the remittance scraper). Monthly for the other 4.
Worked example — Wise vs Western Union for a $300 transfer (illustrative inputs, not a quote):
Wise:
- Effective rate: send $300, recipient receives ~Q2,290 after ~$3.50 fee. Effective rate: 7.63 GTQ/USD. System range (best 7.70, worst 7.10): 88/100.
- Speed: 1-2 business days → 70/100.
- Convenience: bank deposit only, no cash pickup → 60/100.
- Sender flexibility: transfer + debit + credit (3 methods) → 80/100.
- Reliability: high uptime, few complaints → 95/100.
Wise Score = (88 × 0.40) + (70 × 0.25) + (60 × 0.20) + (80 × 0.10) + (95 × 0.05) Wise Score = 35.2 + 17.5 + 12.0 + 8.0 + 4.75 = 77.45/100
Western Union (estimate):
- Effective rate: send $300, recipient receives ~Q2,205 after ~$8 fee and spread. Effective rate: 7.35 GTQ/USD. System range: 50/100.
- Speed: minutes to hours → 95/100.
- Convenience: huge cash pickup network (Banrural, BAM, etc.) → 95/100.
- Flexibility: cash at agent, debit, credit, transfer → 95/100.
- Reliability: established brand but more complaints about hidden fees → 75/100.
WU Score = (50 × 0.40) + (95 × 0.25) + (95 × 0.20) + (95 × 0.10) + (75 × 0.05) WU Score = 20.0 + 23.75 + 19.0 + 9.5 + 3.75 = 76.0/100
Reading the example: with these illustrative inputs Wise wins slightly because the dominant weight (40%) is the effective exchange rate. Real quotes can reverse that input: in our 31 October 2026 feed from Wise’s comparison API, $300 delivered Q2,127.94 with Wise (fee $21.63) and Q2,250.01 with Western Union (fee $1.99). Western Union compensates with speed and convenience. For an urgent $300 transfer where the recipient needs cash within the hour, WU is objectively better despite the slightly lower score — that is why we publish the per-component breakdown, not just the final score.
Limitations:
- Western Union and MoneyGram figures are estimates from the Banguat reference rate + known public margins. Only Wise, Remitly, and Xoom publish directly queryable data.
- The score does not capture recipient preferences (some prefer cash pickup even if they lose on rate; others prefer direct deposit).
- “Reliability” is based on public complaint samples, not official default data.
How we change a weight
If we re-evaluate a weight (for example, giving more importance to speed because diaspora increasingly need instant transfers), the change is documented:
- Publication of the proposal with justification.
- Historical re-calculation of scores with the new weight applied retroactively (so historical charts stay consistent).
- Banner on every affected page for 30 days notifying the methodology change.
General scoring limitations
No score replaces your own evaluation. Three things scores NEVER capture:
- Your specific profile. A bank with a score of 70 could give you the best deal because your credit profile fits them perfectly, while the bank with a score of 85 turns you away.
- Personal service. The quality of your branch advisor can matter more than any number in a table.
- Extraordinary events. If Banguat changes monetary policy tomorrow, all scores age in hours — always verify the timestamp.
Disagree with a weight? Think a component is missing? Email corrections@livinginguatemala.com — weights are reviewed quarterly.

